OFFICE FOR COASTAL MANAGEMENT

Windmill Farm in the ocean

Appeal Decisions

Appeals Spreadsheet – Summary of Coastal Zone Management Act (CZMA) consistency appeals maintained by the Office for Coastal Management.

The following CZMA consistency-appeal decision documents are provided by NOAA’s Office of General Counsel, Oceans and Coasts Section, for public access and information. The documents include decisions to override the state’s objection, not to override the state’s objection, to override the state’s objection on procedural grounds, and to dismiss the appeal. The documents below do not include appeals that were withdrawn or settled (see the Appeals Spreadsheet).

Appellant
State
Appeal Filed
Decision Date
Cangrejos Yacht Club PR 1/2/2014 9/16/2014
Mark Smolinski NY 8/13/2013 4/14/2014
Pan American Grain Co. PR 1/27/2010 12/1/2010
Consistency Appeal of Broadwater Energy LLC and Broadwater Pipeline LLC NY 6/6/2008 4/13/2009
Foothill/Eastern Transportation Corridor Agency CA 2/15/2008 12/18/2008
G. Walter Swain DE 1/31/2008 9/24/2008
Weaver's Cove Energy, LLC, and Mill River Pipeline, LLC MA 8/27/2007 6/26/2008
AES Sparrows Point LNG, LLC, and Mid-Atlantic Express, LLC MD 8/8/2007 6/26/2008
Donald & Susan Williams
NY 7/5/2007 8/29/2007
Prescott Ammarell NY 7/28/2006 11/3/2006
Weaver's Cove Energy, LLC RI 6/26/2006 7/24/2006
Weaver's Cove Energy, LLC RI -- 10/10/2005
Fernando Otero Rodriguez PR 2/03/2005 2/03/2005
Edwin Irizarry Garcia PR 6/15/2004 1/26/2006
Villa Marina Yacht Harbour, Inc. PR 10/31/2003 2/3/2006
Islander East Pipeline Co., LLC CT 11/14/2002 5/5/2004
Walter Taylor MI 11/11/2002 1/3/2003
Millennium Pipeline Co., L.P. NY 6/7/2002 12/12/2003
Peter & Nancy Fenner NY 9/6/2001 8/1/2005
Barnes Nursery, Inc. OH 7/10/2001 12/23/2003
U.S. Erie Island Development Co. OH 2/8/2001 10/22/2004
Jade Venture Group, LLC MI 12/7/2000 11/15/2001
Singleton Development Corp. MS 9/29/2000 5/16/2005
Collier Resources Co. FL 4/3/2000 4/17/2002
Filiberto S. Montalvo Durand PR 2/17/2000 10/25/2000
Alfonzo Cruz Colon PR 2/7/2000 7/11/2000
John T. Keegan PR 10/26/1999 12/5/2003
Ricardo Ramirez PR 5/6/1999 7/20/2000
Fernando Otero Rodriguez PR 4/21/1999 2/3/2005
Pedro Vidal PR 4/21/1999 12/29/2004
Jorge Torres-Martinez PR 4/15/1999 3/26/2003
Luz Torres DeRosa PR 4/14/1999 2/3/2005
Carlos Frontera Colley PR 4/6/1999 10/29/2004
Rick Bellew AL 11/17/1997 7/23/1999
G. Marvin Kuffskie AL 12/16/1996 3/26/1997
Jessie W. Taylor (reissued from earlier case with changes) SC continued 12/28/1998
Jessie W. Taylor SC 4/10/1996 12/28/1998
D'Olive Joint Venture AL 9/22/1994 1/24/1995
Vieques Marine Laboratories PR 4/29/1994 5/28/1996
Joseph M. Mattone NY 3/2/1994 6/19/1997
Jesse Floyd SC 1/7/1993 6/10/1993
Olga Velez Lugo PR 7/9/1992 9/9/1994
ERA PR 5/13/1992 11/29/1994
Mobil Exploration & Producing U.S., Inc. FL 4/29/1992 6/20/1995
Virginia Electric and Power Co. NC 10/3/1991 5/19/1994
Carlos A. Cruz Colon PR 8/26/1991 9/27/1993
Chevron U.S.A., Inc. FL 3/27/1991 1/8/1993
Mobil Oil Exploration & Producing Southeast, Inc. (continuation of earlier cases) NC continued 12/8/1999
Mobil Oil Exploration & Producing Southeast, Inc. NC 12/3/1990 9/2/1994
Robert E. Harris NY 10/26/1990 12/2/1992
Yeamans Hall Club SC 9/25/1990 8/1/1992
Davis Heniford SC 9/24/1990 5/21/1992
Mobil Oil Exploration & Producing Southeast, Inc. NC 7/31/1990 9/2/1994
Claire Pappas NY 3/13/1990 10/26/1992
Eugene J. Dean MA -- 1/24/1992
Roger W. Fuller NC 12/7/1989 10/2/1992
Henry Crosby SC 10/17/1989 12/29/1992
Shickrey Anton SC 10/2/1989 5/21/1991
Jose R. Perez-Villamil PR 8/16/1989 11/20/1991
A. Elwood Chestnut SC 8/14/1989 11/4/1992
Amoco Production Co. AK 4/3/1989 7/20/1990
Jorge L. Guerrero-Calderon PR 3/17/1989 5/5/1993
International Paper Realty Corp. SC 2/2/1989 7/17/1990
Mobil Exploration & Producing U.S., Inc. FL 1/11/1989 1/7/1993
Union Exploration Partners, Ltd. with Texaco. Inc. FL 12/21/1988 1/7/1993
The Asocicion de Propietarios de Los Indios, Inc. PR 9/26/1988 2/19/1992
Michael P. Galgano NY 7/14/1988 10/29/1990
Chevron U.S.A., Inc. CA 7/5/1988 10/29/1990
Texaco, Inc. CA 3/23/1988 5/10/1989
Sucesion Albeto Bachman PR 3/18/1988 10/10/1991
Exxon Co., U.S.A. NY 1/7/1987 6/14/1989
John K. Delyser NY 1/6/1987 2/26/1988
The Korea Drilling Co., Ltd. CA 12/15/1986 1/19/1989
Long Island Lighting Co. NY 11/19/1986 2/26/1988
John Bianci NY 9/5/1985 1/25/1989
Gulf Oil Corp. CA 3/13/1985 12/23/1985
Southern Pacific Transportation Co. CA 10/23/1984 9/24/1985
Exxon Co., U.S.A. CA 3/9/1984 11/14/1984
Union Oil Co. of California CA 12/12/1983 11/9/1984
Ford S. Worthy, Jr. NC 8/5/1983 5/9/1984
Exxon Co., U.S.A. CA 7/22/1983 2/18/1984
Daspit MS -- 1988